Absurdity
God Himself Has Spoken, Through an Excel Formula
Creative people are constantly expected to present their ideas to rational people for approval. Have you ever once seen it happen the other way round?
“They killed it,” a client told me, about something she had spent four months on. “Not rudely. They were very nice about it.”
I asked what the objection had been.
“That’s the thing,” she said. “There wasn’t one. It was more of a feeling. Somebody said it was interesting, and then somebody else said we’d need to be careful, and that was that.”
Four months, ended by an adjective and a note of caution.
4.7 the answer, apparently, and the spreadsheet does not take questions
2 words implicitly paired with “creative” by people under uncertainty in one study: hell, and poison
1 meeting required to kill an idea, against roughly three to defend one
0 post-mortems ever conducted on an idea that was rejected
The Meeting That Never Happens
Creative people are constantly expected to present their ideas to rational people for approval. But have you ever seen the reverse happen?
Have you ever watched an accountant walk into a creative meeting and say: “I’ve run the numbers. The answer is 4.7. But I’m sure you creative types might come up with something completely ridiculous that works even better”?
Of course not. That would be absurd. The numbers have spoken, the spreadsheet has spoken, and apparently God himself has spoken through an Excel formula. Meeting adjourned.
This is the great absurdity of corporate decision-making: the people who are best at protecting the status quo get to decide the fate of those trying to change it.
Rational people hold the power of veto. Creative people get the power of suggestion. One gets to say “that won’t work.” The other has to spend the next three meetings explaining why it might.
And let us be honest — killing an idea is remarkably easy. You do not need imagination, courage, or even a particularly functioning brain. Fold your arms, point at the risks, murmur something about feasibility. Bonus points for “we’ve always done it this way.”
Creating something new, on the other hand, requires you to imagine a possibility that does not yet exist, defend it against people who cannot see it, and somehow prove it will work before you are allowed to try it. Apparently the future must provide references and a five-year track record.
It Is Not Your Imagination
And it turns out this has been measured, which I did not expect.
In 2012 Jennifer Mueller, Shimul Melwani and Jack Goncalo published a paper in Psychological Science with a title that saves everybody time: “The Bias Against Creativity: Why People Desire But Reject Creative Ideas.”
Their finding has two parts, and the second one is the bad news.
First, the bias is implicit. Ask people whether they value creativity and they say yes, enthusiastically, and they mean it. But put them in a state of uncertainty and test what they actually associate with words like creative, inventive and original, and up come words like hell and poison. Nobody in that room thinks they are against new ideas. They would be offended by the suggestion.
Second — and this is the part worth sitting with — the bias interfered with people’s ability to recognise a creative idea at all. Not their willingness to approve it. Their capacity to see what it was.
The researchers point out the irony themselves: uncertainty is precisely what drives organisations to go looking for creative ideas, and uncertainty is precisely what makes them unable to spot one when it arrives.
Which means the person folding their arms is often not being cowardly or political. They genuinely cannot see it. You are describing a colour to somebody who, at that moment, has lost the receptor.
The four months, and the eleven minutes. Photos: Unsplash
Now, In Fairness
I should put the other case, because a creative person complaining about being overruled is not the most impartial witness available.
Most new ideas are bad. Not unfashionable, not ahead of their time — genuinely, straightforwardly bad, including a reasonable proportion of my own. The people who say no are usually right, and an organisation that approved everything would fail considerably faster than one that approves nothing. Scrutiny is not the enemy. Somebody has to ask what it costs.
So the problem is not that the veto exists. The problem is that only one of the two possible mistakes leaves a mark.
Approve a bad idea and there is a budget line, a post-mortem, and your name on it. Kill a good idea and nothing happens at all. No record, no review, no cost, no awkward meeting in eighteen months. The thing that did not get built does not send anybody an invoice.
Which means the incentive is not cowardice. It is accounting. Rejecting is free and approving is not, and people respond to that exactly as you would expect them to.
“We ask creative people to think outside the box, then let people inside the box decide whether they’re allowed to leave.” — And the research suggests that from inside the box, the door is genuinely difficult to see.
What Would Actually Fix It
If rejection is free, make it cost something. Not punitively — just visibly.
Write down what was killed and why. Put a date on it. Look at the list once a year, the way any sensible organisation looks at its failures, and ask how many of those judgments still hold.
Nobody does this. In forty-five years of talking to people about their work I have met many who could describe, in detail, a project that went wrong and what it cost. I have met almost nobody who could show me a list of the ideas their organisation decided against.
That list is the most interesting document a company never writes.
Somewhere in here is a drawer with four months in it. Photos: Unsplash
Back to the Chair
I have an unusual vantage point on this, which is that in my business both people are me.
When I wanted a curved colour-mixing table built to my own drawing rather than buying a rectangular one from a catalogue, there was no meeting. There was simply a man who wanted the curve and a man who had seen the quote, and they had to come to an arrangement, and they are both me and neither of them was entirely reasonable about it.
What I notice, running that argument internally for several decades, is that the cautious one always has the better presentation. He has figures. He has precedent. He can describe exactly what goes wrong, in order, with timings. The other one has a feeling about a shape and absolutely no way to defend it, because the thing he is describing does not exist yet and therefore has no evidence attached.
That is not a fair fight, and it is not a fair fight in anybody’s company either. It is simply that one side is arguing about the world and the other is arguing about a world.
The curve, for the record, was the right call. I could not have proved it to you beforehand. I cannot entirely prove it to you now.
And we wonder why so many organisations struggle to innovate.
The Salon California Journal is a space for ideas, culture, and conversation from my chair in Brasschaat, Belgium. I write about beauty, technology, society, and the intersections between them.